Apple Bans Fortnite, Epic Files Complaint

Reading Time: 4 minutes

In a move that leaves developer Epic Games as the latest in a series of recent high-profile bans being undertaken by Apple, the tech behemoth removed Fortnite from the App Store over Epic’s violation of the App Store’s terms of service.

The ban comes just days after Microsoft ended its testing program for an iOS version of its xCloud streaming gaming service, caused primarily by a clash between the tech giants over Apple’s store policies which made testing of the service nearly impossible, and which would have ultimately made viability of the game-streaming service impossible. In fact, Microsoft wasn’t even first among equals to run into issues with its game-streaming service. Google’s Stadia hasn’t made it to the app store and Apple devices for much the same reasons. In the case of Microsoft xCloud and Google Stadia, Apples restrictive testing policies were cited as being a primary cause for the falling out.

Microsoft is far from the first company to run into serious challenges with developing an app for the iPhone, only to have the app not be approved due to running afoul of Apple’s restrictive development guidelines. However, the ban on Fortnite, which is a perennial best-seller on the App store, is a drastically different situation.

We heard it first from 9to5mac.com that Epic released an update to Fortnite which added an option to make in-app purchases. While it is fairly commonplace to see in-app purchases for games, especially on mobile devices, Epic ran into trouble with Apple because the new update for its in-app purchases allowed users to circumvent Apple’s payment system.

One of the (many) terms for apps to be listed in the app store? All in-app purchases must be processed through the In-App Purchase provided by Apple. The reason for this requirement comes down to Apple’s collection of a hefty 30% commission on all sales through the App-Store and In-App Purchase functions.

Epic sought to circumvent the fee and pass along the savings to its players, with pricing for in-game currency, known and “V-bucks” reflecting a roughly 20 % discount off their app-store pricing. By enabling in-app purchases using its own payment platform, Epic is able to circumvent Apple’s commission collection and give the savings back the the players.

In a statement from Apple to The Verge, they had this to say about Epic’s move:

Today, Epic Games took the unfortunate step of violating the App Store guidelines that are applied equally to every developer and designed to keep the store safe for our users. As a result their Fortnite app has been removed from the store. Epic enabled a feature in its app which was not reviewed or approved by Apple, and they did so with the express intent of violating the App Store guidelines regarding in-app payments that apply to every developer who sells digital goods or services.

Epic has had apps on the App Store for a decade, and have benefited from the App Store ecosystem – including its tools, testing, and distribution that Apple provides to all developers. Epic agreed to the App Store terms and guidelines freely and we’re glad they’ve built such a successful business on the App Store. The fact that their business interests now lead them to push for a special arrangement does not change the fact that these guidelines create a level playing field for all developers and make the store safe for all users. We will make every effort to work with Epic to resolve these violations so they can return Fortnite to the App Store.

Source : The Verge

Epic’s Fortnite update was not exclusive to its iOS version of the game, with an updated Android version rolling out at the same time. Google ultimately took similar action to Apple, and also removed the Fortnite app from the Play Store. According to The Verge, a spokesperson for Google stated “While Fortnite remains available on Android, we can no longer make it available on Play because it violates our policies. However, we welcome the opportunity to continue our discussions with Epic and bring Fortnite back to Google Play.”

What makes the Apple situation more frustrating for Fortnite players and would-be players is that, while Android users still have the option of downloading the Android version without having to go through the Play Store. Because of Apple’s much more restrictive operating environment, obtaining and installing unapproved third-party software outside of the App store is difficult for many, and impossible for most.

In response to the ban, Epic filed a “Complaint for Injunctive Relief” against Apple in the US District Court, Northern District of California, seeking an injunction against Apple in removing the Fortnite app to demand its restoration to the app store and seeking relief from the court, and arguing that Apple’s actions are “monopolistic” and anti-competitive in nature, and making numerous charges of anti-trust violations. (Read the entire 65-page filing here.)

Fortunately fans of Fortnite who had the game downloaded prior to the ban, the copies that are already installed are safe. However, Apple players will ultimately be unable to get any game updates until Fortnite is restored to the app store. Its impossible to say how many weeks or months could pass before any sort of a resolution is reached.

The good news for Android users is that, while they may not be able to currently get the game and its updates via the Play store, the unrestricted ability of developers of 3rd-party software to push software via other pathways means that Android users will suffer no more than a minor inconvenience.

What do you think of Apple’s ban on Fortnite over this? We’d love to hear your thoughts. Comment below and keep the conversation going!

5 1 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
8 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

I have mixed feelings about the App Store guidelines that are being discussed. For one, they charge 30% on all pay transactions. Whether thats in app purchases or when you initially buy the game. To me, isn’t that a cost of doing business? Just like someone developing a game for Xbox or PlayStation, aren’t there licensing fees involved? I don’t know. This is the terms of agreement that these companies signed up for and have them turned their back on them. I do understand but gotta pay to play.

Apples restrictions on game streaming will of course cut in to their market share for Apple Arcade. But in reality, how much are we really talking? In fact, won’t the lack of inclusion as from Microsoft, Sony and Google make them lose market share to Android? As an avid Xbox fan, I’ve been waiting for a long time to get xCloud and cannot tell you how disappointing it was to hear that Apple and Microsoft couldn’t “figure it out” and fix this.

Is Apple worried about the integrity and safety of its platform? Maybe. I like that the Apple App Store is safe and has protected us from malware and hacking (some times). I’m pretty sure they can trust Microsoft, Sony and Google to do the right thing. Apple needs to do the same.

Martin Howard (StarDoggedMoon)

Ya, this is a tough situation. On one hand, Epic went into this knowing the terms but on the other, it feels like just more greed from Apple.

Some may argue that Epic didn’t need to allow Fortnite to be distributed by the Apple Store is just ludicrous. This is a major supply chain and a move as such would be certainly detrimental to any company. Is it fair that Apple in turn expects to gain a commission out of every transaction between Epic and their customers…or else?? Seems kind of like a shakedown to me and perhaps the “in game purchases” model of sales that we often see behind free apps needs to be reconsidered as a result.

I’m certainly not suggesting that Apple deserves no monetary compensation for distribution of another company’s product. Just that perhaps an initial price needs to be considered and then it’s hands off thereafter.

Also, just to play devils advocate here. Do we honestly believe that Epic’s intentions were to “pass the savings on to the customer” for the indefinite future? Moves such as these almost always come with some ulterior motive. Doing it this way may only be a masquerade to hide their own greed. Cos when they put the price back up, they won’t have to share with anyone.

Well said and spot on. I too thought the same. I doubt the cost savings would be shared.

[…] Store and their 30% overhead. Since this is a direct violation of the App Store terms of service, Apple removed Fortnite from the store. Epic Games immediately slapped Apple with a lawsuit, not for money, but for “injunctive […]

[…] Epic Games and Apple continues to heat up as both are firing across each other’s bow after Apple bans Fortnite from the App Store.  On Friday, Apple accused Epic Games’ Tim Sweeney of asking for a special deal prior to […]

[…] included Epic’s own store which violated Apple’s developers’ terms of agreement. Apple in response, banned Fortnite from the App Store and attempted to revoke all of Epic’s developer accounts which means no further iOS […]

[…] hefty 30% markup, and passing on the savings to the customer. The move swiftly resulted in Apple banning Fortnite from the App Store, and serving a two-week ultimatum on Epic that it would terminate its developer […]

[…] handled by Apple. This allows Apple to take a cut of the payment, and has recently sparked a legal battle between Apple and game developer Epic Games, when a recent update to its Fortnite title implemented the ability for Apple users to make these […]

8
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x